Blog Reading
Home » Blog » Questions » Are there differences between buck and flyback?

Are there differences between buck and flyback?

On paper its the 1:N term... In practice the differences are massive because of snubbers, control, isolation, etc....

Do the basic math on both. You'll see advantages on both sides of the design on paper which aren't too many, but as other people have stated here... You need to define your spec a little better so that we can help because they are two very different switchers which solve two very different problems.

1. Do you need isolation between the AC line and ground (and how much)? (this question alone decides for you if you need a flyback...)

2. What is your efficiency requirement?
Because of the isolation and other issues, most likely the buck will be more efficient.

3. Will you need to meet any FCC or EN spec on conducted or radiated emissions?
Fly backs can be noisier depending on switching frequency, at your power level it may not be to be a that large of an issue... until you fail, then your screwed...

4. What is your cost requirement?
The buck will cost significantly less... no need for an isolated transformer, cheaper fets/igbt because you won't need an 800V part (and with 230Vac in you will need an 800V part, EMI parts will most likely cost less, etc... If you need an opto-isolator (tighter control of output voltages), that will cost you more too.

5. Where is this switcher going or what's the purpose? (powering a digital circuit or gate drive for a bigger design) This more relate to: What's the output ripple requirement (voltage and current)? What are your load transients that you need to meet? Define this and it will help choose.

6. Do you really need a fresh design?
I hate to mention an off the shelf component versus doing your own design. But designing and building a switcher costs development time (easily a month or two if your laying out a board as well). It's a lot easier to build a footprint for a part that meets your needs (assuming it meets your cost requirements) vs. doing a whole new fresh design. Just getting through EMI/EMC testing alone on a production design will set you back a fair amount of lab time plus and time to fix and clear up things to meet requirements versus buying something like this: VSK-S15-48U ($20 in quantity on digikey and probably meets all your requirements including all the EMI/EMC requirements which is not trivial).

You may also like:

Variable Frequency Drives (VFD) that do not have either an AC line reactor or a DC bus choke, will typically exhibit a THDi greater than 85% at all loading conditions. The THDi is dependent on the conduction ...
The motor I need to stop is a 90W Single Phase Permanent Capacitor Induction motor, run straight from 230V AC mains. I'm not able to use a variable speed drive, separate DC injection braking unit or a DC ...
Before the proper spacing of ground rods can be determined, the site needs to be evaluated to determine the soil conductivity. Some of the software programs used for grounding system design resulted in ...
I was recently trying to connect my Delta VFD E series drive with my laptop using Vfd-Soft software (which I downloaded from Delta website) and RJ 45 to USB converter(RS232/RS485 converter). I connected the ...
In DC breaking, frequency inverter injects DC current in stator of Motor & with that DC current Stator will try to lock the rotor. There will be stationary field instead of rotating field in between stator ...
service The engineers in AC Drive China are very professional in Chinese automation industrial control fields, provide you comprehensive energy saving solutions.

Hot Tags

Featured

Frequency directly represents no of rotation of rotor for that machine, the higher the frequency the more the rotation of the rotor, i.e. the rpm of the motor there by result ... Due to power electronics technology and microelectronics technology rapid development, variable frequency drive reforms and upgrades speed also is faster, introduce new products, ... Since the 21st century, China variable frequency drive industry is highly fission. Many foreign brands begin to set up factories in China, the implementation of the localization ... My personal preference is for an AC line reactor simply because it does a better job of protecting the variable frequency drive from the line and the line from the drive. I've ... As nowadays there is a trend in green energy production and energy efficiency, what solutions/applications would you recommend in reduction consumed energy of a motor driven by ...

What's New